Saturday Night Live opening title

We Know Why the SNL Skit “Sisters” Went Viral – You Do Too

By Stephen J. Silverberg
New York Elder Law Attorney

Saturday Night Live sketches don’t always hit their mark. But the recent sketch “Sister,” featuring John Mulaney, has struck a nerve with millions of people who recognize an uncomfortable reality about caring for aging parents: In many families, the responsibility falls disproportionately on daughters.

The sketch is funny because it is painfully accurate. A son realizes his aging father needs help, but rather than arranging for professional care, sharing responsibilities with siblings, or developing a plan, he discovers the perfect solution. His sister will provide 24-hour care, for free, while he returns to his own life.

The joke becomes less funny if you know how closely it resembles the experiences of families across the country.

In our estate planning and elder care practice, we see this dynamic regularly. Daughters take time off from work to bring their parents to medical appointments. They manage medications, coordinate home health aides, communicate with doctors, handle insurance issues, shop for groceries, prepare meals, and make sure their parents are safe. They may move into their parents’ homes or relocate their parents into their own homes.

And when their parents die, they are often the ones left handling the estate, sorting through financial records, paying bills, arranging funerals, and dealing with the legal process—even when brothers and other siblings live nearby.

The SNL sketch may be comedy, but the consequences of unequal caregiving are anything but funny.

The Unequal Burden of Family Caregiving

Family caregiving is not limited to helping an aging parent get to the doctor once in a while. As an older adult’s health declines, the responsibilities can become a full-time job.

A caregiver may be responsible for bathing, dressing, toileting, preparing meals, managing medications, monitoring cognitive decline, coordinating appointments, dealing with insurance companies, and responding to emergencies. Care may be required during the day, overnight, on weekends, and during holidays.

The work can be physically exhausting, emotionally draining, and financially damaging. A daughter who reduces her working hours or leaves her job to care for a parent may lose wages, career opportunities, employer-sponsored benefits, retirement contributions, and future Social Security income.

The burden is not shared equally among adult children.

Research has repeatedly documented the gender imbalance in family caregiving. A study published in the American Sociological Review by Angela Grigoryeva found that daughters provide substantially more care to aging parents than sons. Other research has found that sons provide less care when daughters are available, even when the daughters have employment and family obligations of their own.

The result is a familiar pattern: One child becomes the primary caregiver, while the others are involved only intermittently. The primary caregiver is expected to absorb the work, without compensation, while the entire family benefits from the parent’s continued care at home.

The caregiver’s time, financial security, health, and personal life may be sacrificed, and even if these contributions are reflected in the parent’s estate plan, the other siblings will resent the different inheritances. Litigation often follows.

Caregiving Is Not Free, Even When No One Is Paid

Families sometimes assume that caregiving is simply something a daughter, sister, or adult child should do because it is the right thing to do. But unpaid caregiving carries real economic consequences.

When a daughter leaves work to care for a parent, she may lose years of earnings. She may have difficulty returning to the workforce after the parent dies or enters a nursing home. Her retirement savings may suffer, and she may be forced to rely on her spouse, her own savings, or other family members.

Meanwhile, siblings who have not provided care may continue earning income, advancing their careers, contributing to retirement accounts, and maintaining their own households.

This disparity becomes particularly painful when the parent dies and the estate is divided equally among the children. The caregiver may have spent years providing services that would otherwise have cost the family thousands of dollars per month, only to receive the same inheritance as siblings who provided little or no care.

That is when family resentment often becomes a legal problem.

When Caregiving Turns Into an Estate Dispute

We have seen families argue over whether a caregiving daughter should receive a larger inheritance because of the time, effort, and financial sacrifice she made.

Some siblings believe the estate should be divided equally, regardless of who provided care. Others believe the child who cared for the parent should be compensated or receive a greater share of the estate.

Neither position necessarily reflects what the parent wanted.

Without a clear estate plan addressing the issue, families may find themselves arguing over the parent’s intentions after the parent has died. Disputes may involve allegations that a caregiver improperly influenced the parent, changed a will or trust, transferred money, or received financial benefits that were not justified. In some cases, litigation may follow.

The cost of estate litigation can be substantial. It can consume estate assets, delay distributions, damage relationships, and force family members to revisit years of personal conflict in a courtroom. Even families that ultimately settle may spend considerable money and time trying to resolve disagreements that could have been addressed through planning.

The law does not automatically provide a caregiver with additional compensation simply because that caregiver performed more work. Nor does the law necessarily require an estate to be divided equally if the parent has made a valid estate plan providing otherwise.

The parent’s wishes, the governing documents, and the circumstances surrounding any transfers or changes to the estate plan matter.

That is why these conversations should take place while the parent still has the capacity to make decisions.

Caregiver Agreements: A Way to Compensate Family Members

There is a legal way to compensate a family member for caregiving services while protecting the older adult’s assets and addressing potential Medicaid eligibility concerns. It is commonly called a caregiver agreement, personal services contract, or personal care agreement.

These agreements can establish that a family member is being paid for actual services rather than receiving a gift of the parent’s money. But they must be structured properly. Simply transferring money to a daughter who has been providing care does not automatically make the transfer legitimate compensation.

Generally, a caregiver agreement should be written before the services are performed, clearly describe the duties the caregiver will provide, establish reasonable compensation, and specify when and how payments will be made. Compensation should reflect the fair market value of the services rather than an arbitrary amount chosen by the family.

The agreement may cover services such as:

  • Transportation to medical appointments and other necessary outings.
  • Medication management and coordination with medical providers.
  • Assistance with bathing, dressing, toileting, and other personal needs.
  • Meal preparation, grocery shopping, and household tasks.
  • Financial and administrative assistance, including bill payment and appointment scheduling.
  • Supervision and assistance with activities of daily living.

The agreement should also address the expected schedule, payment terms, the duration of the arrangement, and what happens if the caregiver becomes unavailable.

The Documentation Problem

Although caregiver agreements can provide an important legal framework, the documentation requirements can be demanding.

Caregivers may be expected to maintain detailed records of the services they perform, the time spent providing those services, appointments attended, expenses incurred, and payments received. Records may need to distinguish between personal care, transportation, household work, and administrative responsibilities.

In practical terms, this can mean documenting when the caregiver arrives and leaves, recording medical appointments, maintaining receipts, tracking expenditures from the parent’s accounts, and keeping a daily log of care provided.

For a person providing around-the-clock care, the amount of recordkeeping is punitive. The caregiver is already managing the parent’s physical needs, medical appointments, medications, household, and emergencies. Requiring detailed records of every activity adds another layer of responsibility to an already exhausting situation.

Yet those records may become critical if Medicaid later reviews the parent’s financial transactions to determine eligibility for long-term care benefits.

Payments made to family members without adequate documentation may be viewed as gifts or uncompensated transfers. Depending on the circumstances and applicable Medicaid rules, those transfers can result in a period of Medicaid ineligibility when the parent needs nursing home coverage.

A properly drafted agreement, supported by records showing that the services were actually provided and the payments were reasonable, can help establish that the parent received fair value in exchange for the money.

Caregiver Compensation Can Have Tax Consequences

Families must also understand that caregiver compensation is not necessarily tax-free. Payments made under a caregiver agreement may constitute taxable income to the caregiver. Depending on the nature of the relationship and how the arrangement is structured, there may also be employment tax, withholding, reporting, or other tax obligations.

This is an important distinction. A caregiver agreement is not a way to transfer money tax-free to a family member. It is a legal arrangement for compensating services, and the tax consequences must be considered.

Families should consult an elder law attorney and tax professional before entering into an agreement. The arrangement should be structured to comply with applicable Medicaid rules, tax requirements, and other relevant laws.

The goal is to compensate a family member fairly without jeopardizing the older adult’s financial security or future eligibility for care.

Medicaid Disputes Can Leave Caregivers and Parents Vulnerable

Medicaid rules can make caregiver compensation particularly complicated. Families may believe they are simply paying a daughter for services she has been providing, only to discover that the state considers the payments uncompensated transfers when the parent applies for Medicaid.

A New York case illustrates why careful planning matters.

In Matter of Scott v. Zucker, 129 A.D.3d 1527 (2015), a parent had entered into a personal services agreement with his daughter and son-in-law, providing for payments of $5,000 per month for care and services. The agreement did not identify specific services. Payments were irregular, and the caregivers withdrew money from the parent’s account to pay their own expenses. When the parent entered a nursing home, a substantial transfer was made.

The Medicaid agency determined that the transfers were uncompensated. The family challenged the determination, but the Appellate Division upheld it. The court noted the lack of documentation showing what services had actually been provided and the absence of evidence establishing the fair market value of those services.

The case demonstrates that a caregiver agreement alone is not enough. The agreement must be properly structured and supported by evidence that the services were actually performed and that the compensation was reasonable.

It also demonstrates why families should not wait until a nursing home admission or Medicaid application is imminent to address caregiving arrangements.

When Siblings Put Inheritance Ahead of Care

The most troubling family disputes are not always about the caregiver receiving compensation. Sometimes, the dispute is about whether the parent should spend money on care at all.

We have encountered situations in which one adult child wanted to hire a home health aide to assist a mother, while another sibling opposed the expense. The objection was not necessarily based on the mother’s needs or her safety. Instead, the concern was that spending the mother’s money would reduce the inheritance that sibling expected to receive.

We have also seen situations in which family members wanted a parent declared incapacitated but objected to compensating the sibling who was providing virtually all of the care.

These conflicts raise serious questions about financial decision-making, fiduciary responsibilities, and the parent’s rights. An adult child does not have a legal right to an inheritance during the parent’s lifetime. The parent’s assets belong to the parent and should be used for the parent’s needs, wishes, and benefit—not preserved simply because an adult child expects to inherit them.

When someone is acting under a power of attorney or as a guardian, that person may have legal duties to act in the parent’s best interests. Decisions about care, spending, and compensation should be based on the older adult’s needs and applicable law, not on sibling expectations.

These situations can become especially complicated when the parent has cognitive impairment and can no longer clearly express preferences or independently manage financial affairs.

That is precisely why planning for incapacity is so important.

America Has a Caregiving Problem

The SNL sketch also highlights a larger problem: The United States places enormous responsibility on families to provide long-term care, often with limited financial or practical support.

Medicare generally does not pay for ongoing custodial care—the assistance many older adults need with bathing, dressing, eating, and other daily activities. Medicaid may cover certain long-term care services for individuals who meet eligibility requirements, but eligibility rules, available services, and program limitations vary. Families who do not qualify for public assistance may find themselves facing substantial costs for home care, assisted living, or nursing home care.

In other countries, caregivers may have access to more extensive paid leave, public benefits, subsidized home care, or national long-term care insurance programs. The United States has programs that provide support in some circumstances, but access is uneven and families often bear significant responsibility themselves.

The financial consequences can be devastating. The daughter who becomes the primary caregiver may lose income and retirement security while also paying out-of-pocket for supplies, transportation, food, and other expenses. Her siblings may not appreciate the financial impact because they are not experiencing it firsthand.

The burden is particularly difficult for women who are also raising children, working, or caring for their own spouses. They may be part of the sandwich generation, caring for aging parents while managing responsibilities to their own families.

Caregiving should not require a family member to sacrifice her own financial future simply because no one discussed a plan.

How Families Can Protect Themselves: Plan Before a Crisis

There is no easy solution to the emotional and financial challenges of caring for aging parents. But families can reduce the likelihood of conflict by planning ahead.

1. Have the difficult conversations early. Discuss where parents want to live if they can no longer live independently, what types of care they would prefer, and how they expect to pay for that care. Do not wait until an emergency, hospitalization, or diagnosis forces the family to make decisions under pressure.

2. Discuss caregiving responsibilities among siblings. Care should not automatically fall to the daughter who lives closest, has the most flexible schedule, or has historically taken responsibility for family matters. Each sibling should be asked to contribute in a meaningful way. Contributions may include providing hands-on care, paying for services, managing bills, arranging appointments, researching care options, or providing respite.

3. Consider whether a caregiver agreement is appropriate. If a family member will provide substantial ongoing services, discuss whether compensation is appropriate and whether a formal agreement should be established. Compensation should be addressed before services are performed and should comply with applicable legal and tax requirements.

4. Review estate planning documents. A will or trust should reflect the parent’s wishes. If a parent wants to compensate a child who has provided extensive care, that intention should be discussed with an estate planning attorney and documented appropriately. Do not assume that an informal promise or verbal understanding will prevent future disputes.

5. Plan for incapacity. A durable power of attorney, health care proxy, and other appropriate documents can help ensure that someone the parent trusts has authority to make financial and medical decisions when necessary. Planning should also address who will manage the parent’s finances and how that person will be accountable.

6. Understand the financial and Medicaid implications. Before transferring assets, paying a family member, changing an inheritance, or entering into a caregiver agreement, obtain legal advice. A transaction that appears reasonable within the family may have unintended consequences for Medicaid eligibility, taxes, or estate administration.

7. Recognize that caregiving needs change. A plan that works when a parent needs occasional help may no longer be adequate when the parent develops dementia, becomes unable to walk safely, or requires supervision around the clock. Families should revisit their arrangements as circumstances change.

The Conversation “Sister” Started Is One We Need to Continue

The SNL sketch has created a national conversation. Women are sharing their experiences, siblings are confronting uncomfortable truths, and families are beginning to recognize how often caregiving responsibilities are assumed rather than discussed.

Millions of women  are exhausted, financially strained, and quietly managing the needs of aging parents while everyone else assumes they will continue doing so.

As elder law attorneys, we see how caregiving responsibilities intersect with incapacity planning, Medicaid eligibility, estate administration, inheritance disputes, and family relationships. These issues do not occur in isolation. A decision made today about caregiving or financial support may have consequences years later.

The best way to protect your family is to plan. Discuss incapacity, caregiving, compensation, finances, and inheritance while everyone has the opportunity to participate. Make your wishes clear. Put appropriate legal documents in place. Understand the consequences of the decisions you make.

Love and family responsibility should not become the foundation for resentment, financial hardship, or litigation.

The “Sister” sketch may have made us laugh, but it also reminds us that caring for aging parents is a family responsibility—and one that deserves thoughtful planning, fairness, and compassion.

About the Author
Stephen J. Silverberg is nationally recognized as a leader in the areas of estate planning, estate administration, asset preservation planning, and elder law. He is a past president of the prestigious National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys (NAELA), and a founding member and past president of the New York State chapter of NAELA.